
One of my best friends asked me for my top five favorite films of all time while we chatted on Facebook a week ago. Though we agreed that our favorite movies are constantly shifting, he insisted that one’s favorite three movies generally stay the same. I don’t agree, but I’ll entertain the premise. He regaled me with his sophisticated choices: Aguierre, the Wrath of God (1973), Apocalypse Now! (1979) and Barry Lyndon (1975). I looked at those choices and immediately felt like a chump. Herzog, Copolla, Kubrick. Perhaps three of the finest directors of all time, all represented, all intense films that require extensive thought and English major-esque discussion afterward. The first time I saw Barry Lyndon with this guy, we stayed up until 6:00 in the morning discussing the scenery and costumes.
“I have to go hit the bank quick,” he said. “Think about it. I’ll be back in a few minutes.”
He was at work, I was in the basement registering for courses. I thought heavily for a minute. My top ten lists are always lighthearted with a few heavies thrown in for good measure. I adore the movies he mentioned (especially Aguierre), but when it comes to movie-going, my choices are seemingly (but, I’d argue, not) inconsequential: American Splendor, Stranger Than Fiction, Nobody’s Fool, Broadcast News, Dazed and Confused, Catch Me If You Can. Not revolutionary pics, but thoroughly enjoyable and well-scripted ones that make you smile again and again and again. The characters in each of these movies are memorable, interesting, and perfectly developed. And, on an off night, you can always pop them in and enjoy the small nuances of each personality.
Anyway, my Top Three right now, as of late-April, 2010: Annie Hall, Five Easy Pieces, and Almost Famous. Famous has never left my top three list, not since I was 16 years old. My friend’s list is different in many ways, but when he came back, he looked at the list and chuckled. I ardently defended Almost Famous before he spoke a word: “Hey man, this is the most feel-good pic of all time…It’s nothing short of beautiful. I know, it seems a little bit too…you know, not ‘70s, it’s not heavy like your shit…” I felt like I’d fucked up, choosing shit like Almost Famous when I should’ve picked Raging Bull or The Godfather.
But he cut me off mid-justification, laughed and agreed. This movie makes you happy. Cameron Crowe makes the entire ‘70s rock spectacle—the drugs, the sex, the drinking—all surprisingly romantic, and that’s the pic’s greatest asset. On a shitty night, you can throw Famous in and watch William Miller (Patrick Fugit) chase rockstars from Stillwater trying desperately to get his interviews. It’s the life that many of us wished we lived at age 15. Anyone with an ounce of taste wishes they were William Miller when they were 15, even if he is a total nerd.
Read more…